7 February 2009
CP Rail Dispute Safety Record Following Several Derailments
A railway workers union president is clashing with Canadian
Pacific Rail over safety after several train derailments in the past two weeks.
The president of the union representing railway maintenance workers is calling on Canadian Pacific Rail to invest more money in its
lines, but the company maintains its safety record is tops in North America.
William Brehl, who heads the Teamsters Canada Rail Conference, said he's looking for the company to inject cash after a
20-car derailment in west Quebec.
No one was hurt when the cargo train went off the tracks near Dalhousie Mills, Que. at about 4 a.m. Friday.
Most of the cars were empty, while four were carrying used automotive parts.
Several minor and two major derailments have also occurred on the CP Rail lines in Canmore, Alberta, and Thunder Bay, Ontario, since
late January.
"We're concerned that the infrastructure of the railways in Canada isn't at a safety level it should be at," Mr. Brehl said,
adding he believes the latest incident could have been avoided.
On 3 Feb 2009, the union sent a letter to Transport Canada outlining concerns that the line carrying those cars was in
disrepair, Mr. Brehl said.
He added the same line had been earmarked for maintenance since 2005.
"I think there's a direct correlation. When you stop doing the maintenance [and] when you stop taking care of the track - but you
keep running trains - eventually they go on the ground."
However, there was no letter or conversation about the same concern received by CP Rail, said its spokesman Mark Seland.
"It's irresponsible to indicate that an accident was unavoidable when a determination of cause has not been made," he said,
adding it can take days or months to conduct an investigation.
CP Rail doesn't dispute the derailments occurred, but there haven't been more than usual, Mr. Seland said.
"Canadian Pacific is the safest railway in North America and it has been for the 10 of the past 12 years," he said,
referring to a designation by the U.S.-based Federal Railroad Administration.
"Canadian Pacific has the lowest frequency of train incidents per year in all of North America."
Mr. Brehl said he believes the derailments are resulting from cuts by the company to previously planned upkeep work and track and
equipment maintenance staff.
However, Mr. Seland said CP Rail takes care in prioritizing where work is done, and, while layoffs have occurred in the system, it
didn't include workers in the area of the recent derailment.
"Across 25,760 kilometres and 2,000 track maintenance workers, plans can change daily. It doesn't represent any sort of
systematic easement of safety practices."
|
