|
|
|
|
|
|
4 November 2004
Can't Add More
Trains Without Capacity Upgrades
If GO Transit chairman
Gordon Chong is going to dabble in railway history to gain better access to the tracks of the
Canadian Pacific and Canadian National Railways, he ought to get it right. Instead, he has twisted
history to suit his flaming rhetoric.
Contrary to Chong, the CPR did not bribe Sir John A. Macdonald to get tax dollars to build the
transcontinental main line. It was another company. That discredited firm and Macdonald's own
government fell as a result. The deal with today's 123-year-old CPR to build "the
wedding band of Confederation" has often been assessed as perhaps the first and one of the most
successful public-private partnerships in Canadian history.
Second, it is grossly unfair to use the sacrifices made by Chinese railway labourers - and other
native-born workers and immigrants from other lands - to secure concessions from today's
railways. The whole episode comes from a thankfully, bygone era with different national mores and
values. Remember, lament and applaud the efforts of those labourers, but don't use their hardships to
redress current commercial grievances.
Even more disturbing is Chong's apparent lack of understanding of the state of our railways. Every
major North American line has been declared by regulatory agencies on both sides of the border to be
revenue inadequate. As a result, much of the railway system is being stretched to the limit by
increased traffic and inadequate capacity. Chong shouldn't expect to add commuter trains to this
strained physical plant without investing in capacity upgrades that will keep passengers and freight
flowing.
The way to resolve these problems and create a better lot for all users is through reasoned debate
and negotiation. What Chong has offered up is the opposite.
That's bad for commuters, freight shippers, railroaders and the public in general. I would have
expected better of someone representing a transit agency I have always admired and praised repeatedly
in my work as a transportation writer and analyst.
Greg Gormick - Toronto
|
|
|